The dairy industry in Kazakhstan is facing a pressing issue that has put the stability of the sector at risk. With the influx of cheap Chinese dry milk and Russian dairy products, local dairy processors are struggling to compete. This shift in the market has led to a significant drop in the farmgate price of raw milk, impacting local farmers and the overall industry.
Why is this happening and what are the implications for the Kazakh dairy sector? Let’s delve into the details to understand the complexities of this situation and its potential impact on the local economy.
The Shift from Raw Milk to Dry Milk
In recent years, Kazakhstan dairy processing plants have transitioned from buying raw milk from local farmers to importing dry milk from Russia. This change has been driven by the competitive pricing of dry milk, particularly from Chinese suppliers. As a result, several dairy plants in the Pavlodar and eastern Kazakhstan regions have suspended raw milk purchases from local farmers.
The farmgate price of raw milk in Kazakhstan has seen a sharp decline, dropping from KZT 250 (US$0.52) at the beginning of the year to nearly KZT 150 (US$0.31) in June. This rapid decrease has had a significant impact on local farmers who depend on selling their milk to sustain their livelihoods.
The Competitive Landscape
The influx of cheap Russian dairy products, coupled with the competitive pricing of Chinese dry milk, has put immense pressure on the Kazakh raw milk sector. Policymakers have raised concerns about the long-term sustainability of the industry, as local players struggle to compete with imported products.
Over the past five years, Kazakhstan’s dairy imports from Russia have increased sixfold, with a noticeable acceleration in growth in recent months. This surge in imports has raised alarms among industry stakeholders, who fear the consequences of relying heavily on foreign dairy products.
The Consequences for Local Farmers
The shift towards imported dry milk and Russian dairy products has had dire consequences for local farmers in Kazakhstan. Some farmers have already been forced into bankruptcy due to the plummeting farmgate prices of raw milk. This has created a challenging environment for small-scale producers who are unable to compete with the prices offered by larger dairy processors.
The situation has also highlighted a lack of support for local farmers in Kazakhstan, as they struggle to sustain their operations in the face of stiff competition from imported products. The need for intervention and policy changes to protect the interests of local farmers has become increasingly urgent.
The Debate on Consumer Patriotism
Despite criticism from policymakers and industry stakeholders, Kazakh dairy processors have defended their reliance on imported dairy products. Some argue that the domestic raw milk sector is not sufficiently efficient and that the quality of milk sourced from local farms does not meet industry standards.
Andrey Gritsenko, CEO of Eurasian Milk LLP, a prominent dairy processor, has highlighted the challenges faced by Kazakh dairy farmers. He points to issues such as low farm efficiency, high production costs, poor milk quality, hygiene concerns, and contamination with harmful microorganisms as factors that limit the competitiveness of local raw milk.
The Role of Imports in Food Inflation
On the other hand, Kazakhstan dairy processors argue that importing affordable raw materials from Russia helps them keep food inflation in check. By leveraging cost-effective inputs, processors can maintain competitive pricing for dairy products in the local market. This strategy has enabled them to offer affordable products to consumers amidst rising global food prices.
However, the reliance on imports also exposes the Kazakh dairy industry to external market fluctuations and geopolitical risks. Changes in trade policies or disruptions in the supply chain can have a direct impact on the availability and pricing of raw materials, affecting the stability of the sector.
The Path Forward
As the debate over the future of the Kazakh dairy sector intensifies, policymakers are facing mounting pressure to address the challenges facing local farmers and processors. Calls for import restrictions and measures to support domestic production have been raised, urging lawmakers to intervene to protect the interests of local stakeholders.
Within the Eurasia Economic Union, Kazakhstan’s options for safeguarding its domestic market are limited due to the common customs framework with Russia and Belarus. This poses a unique challenge for policymakers seeking to balance the interests of local producers with the broader economic considerations of regional trade agreements.
In conclusion, the dairy industry in Kazakhstan is at a crossroads, grappling with the implications of shifting market dynamics and increased competition from foreign suppliers. The debate over the future of the sector highlights the complexities of balancing economic interests with the need to support local farmers and processors. As stakeholders continue to navigate these challenges, collaboration between industry players and policymakers will be crucial in shaping the path forward for the Kazakh dairy sector.
If you found this article insightful and want to stay updated on the latest developments in the dairy industry, subscribe to Cattle Weekly’s newsletter for exclusive content and industry insights. Join the conversation by sharing your thoughts and experiences in the comments below. Let’s work together to support the future of the Kazakh dairy sector.
